News

FCA Permits Licence Sale While Creditor PPSR Claims Remain Unresolved

Written by David McCrostie | Nov 16, 2026, 4:30:13 AM

Healey v I’m Organic Pty Ltd (FCA 2026)

 

 

 

Brief facts

 

Global Loan Agency Services Australia Specialist Activities Pty Ltd (GLAS) appointed Receivers over a group of companies, which included AC Invest Hospitality Trading Pty Ltd (the Company).

 

The Company held the liquor licence for Sydney’s Lady Hampshire Hotel; the venue included nine gaming machine entitlements. The Receivers proposed selling the licence after the hotel stopped operating, however there was an ongoing dispute as to who had priority over the license and the proceeds of its sale.

 

The competing security claims created uncertainty about the Receivers’ ability to sell. I’m Organic had a security which was registered before GLAS’s security. YPD Finance also claimed priority over GLAS, despite registering later. 

 

The Receivers feared legal claims if they sold, and a loss of value if they delayed.

 

Judgment

 

The issues in this matter were:

  • whether the Receivers could sell despite I’m Organic’s prior registered security; 

  • whether judicial advice was appropriate; and 

  • whether YPD Finance should be added as a party.

The Receivers’ concerns were:

  • that they were unable to carry out their duties without risking the sale of the gaming machine entitlements at an impaired value; 

  • a claim against them if they attempted to sell the entitlements; and 

  • on the other hand, a claim if they do not take prompt steps to sell the entitlements. 

 

These concerns were compounded by the possibility of imminent legislative changes that could affect demand and the value of the gaming machine entitlements.

 

The Receivers submitted that, while they considered the Company to have clear title, they were genuinely concerned about personal exposure to a claim for damages and other liability if they proceeded with the sale without the benefit of judicial advice.

 

The FCA authorised the sale under s420B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). It found that the sale was in the interests of the Company and its creditors, and that holding the net proceeds in trust adequately protected the competing claims.

 

Although I’m Organic’s director had indicated consent through a third party, direct confirmation had not been obtained despite reasonable efforts. The Court proceeded cautiously by making the sale order; it did not prescribe a particular form of consent.

 

The FCA also gave directions under s424 that the Receivers were justified in proceeding. This addressed genuine legal risks, rather than simply endorsing a commercial decision. YPD Finance was added because its claimed rights could be directly affected.

 

Implications

 

For receivers and secured creditors, the decision illustrates a practical way to separate an urgent sale from a dispute about payment priority. Seek clear consent, involve affected creditors and document why delay risks value. 

 

Where court orders are needed, arrangements preserving the sale proceeds can help protect creditors without holding up the sale. 

 

The Court’s approval does not resolve priority disputes or entitlement to the proceeds, nor does it provide blanket protection for receivers.